DECCAN INQUIRER
Bi-Weekly e news paper
Editor: Nagaraja.M.R.... Vol.04.....Issue.42...............27 / 05 / 2023
Caste Reservation or Discrimination Vengeance ?
- An appeal to Honourable Supreme Court of India
The “Caste based Reservation Acts “ by government of india and state governments are reverse discrimination , gross violation of human rights , acts of vengeance. The authors of Constitution of India have committed crimes , human rights violations against numerically small financially socially poor castes like brahmins , vyshyas , others. Nobody , no highest constitutional functionaries, no judges have the right to violate other human being's human rights. In this backdrop authors of Constitution of india are human rights violators , criminals.
Reservation act is passed by majority in indian parliament. In the same way during Hitler's reign Oppressive policies against jews were passed by majority in german parliament. Mere majority , mere numbers cannot make an inhuman act into humane or injustice into justice.
Our freedom fighters struggled, sacrificed to build an ideal country free from any biases. Freedom fighters belonging to all castes, religions including brahmins, dalits , muslims , others have sacrificed a lot in freedom struggle. After independence people belonging to all castes and religions are paying taxes to the government. In spite of all this numerically dominant castes are usurping public resources , opportunities by suppressing , discriminating numerically minor castes like brahmins , vyshyas. Where is equality , equal opportunity?
Every human being including brahmins have human rights of equal rights , equal opportunity and equitable justice even if Constitution cheats them of the same.
The Caste based reservation acts are passed by majority in parliament fine. In the same way inhuman acts of suppression of Jews were passed by majority in Nazi Germany parliament. Brute numerical majority doesn't make an inhuman act as human or injustice as justice.
From time immemorial numerically dominant castes were ruling village panchayaths to big kingdoms. People of dominant castes were village panchayath heads to kings, they ruled enforced discriminatory rules , untouchability in their jurisdictions.
Today's parliament and state legislature s since independence are occupied by dominant caste members. They have made brahmins as scape goats for all the ills , untouchability. Does it mean kings & village panchayath heads of yester years were foolish and acted as per brahmin's advices only ? Then why don't you credit brahmins for good things done in yester years ?
Every caste and religion including brahmins are guilty of practicing untouchability against dalits but not brahmins alone.
Only dalits need caste based affirmative actions to remove caste based social stigma.
All other castes , religions doesn't need OBC , GROUP A , GROUP B , etc tags and reservation. They must get affirmative actions based on their economic status rather than their caste. Numerically , politically dominant castes have usurped public resources by classifying their own castes as backward.
There are rich as well as poor people in all castes and religions. Poor in all castes and religions need support by government and society. But rich people in so called reserved category doesn't need government support instead it must be given to the poor among the same reserved category. Affirmative actions must be based on latest transparent people census including details of caste , religion , education , property , income , etc not on decades old census. There is a huge change from 1947 to 2023.
Children should not be punished for the crimes committed by their grand father.
Also punishing a criminal ( of minor caste) for his crimes is right but letting his accomplices, crime partners ( belonging to dominant castes ) free is not right.
Now many state governments have unscientifically declared people of dominant castes as backward castes and granted them reservation benefits even crossing 50% reservation cap by SCI. There are many families of reserved category where both parents are government employees and getting more than one lakh rupees monthly salary , still government declares them backward and their son gets fee waiver , scholarships , etc in college. Whereas a brahmin worker earning three hundred rupees in daily wages is declared as forward caste by government and his son studying in college is denied fee waiver scholarships , etc like his backward class classmate. Unable to pay fees he drops out of college.
Is this the India our freedom fighters struggled sacrificed for ?
Hereby we appeal to Honourable Supreme Court of India :
1. To order government of india and state governments to conduct time bound transparent people census.
2. To annul all discriminatory reservation acts by government.
3. To order government to base it's affirmative policies on actual conditions of people irrespective of caste or religion.
4. To limit reservation benefits only once to a family. Father gets job on reservation quota again his son should not get job on reservation instead a person of same reserved category who has not got reservation benefits earlier should get it.
5. To provide equal opportunity for every person irrespective of caste or religion in all spheres.
Your's sincerely
Nagaraja M R
Dr.B.R.Ambedkar against permanent Reservation Policy
In his minority view on the Bench, Justice S. Ravindra Bhat reminded Baba Saheb Ambedkar’s observations that reservations should be seen as temporary and exceptional “or else they would eat up the rule of equality”.
Reservation or Oppression or Vengeance ?
A GO issued by the Madras Presidency in 1921 allocated 44% of reservations to non-Brahmins, 16% to Muslims, 16% to Anglo-Indian Christians, and 8% to Scheduled Castes. 100% fully reserved. No jobs , no college seats, no government support for Brahmins. Are not brahmins citizens of india ? Are not brahmins tax payers to the government ? There are many Brahmins who struggled and sacrificed for our freedom struggle like other communities.
Britishers sowed the seeds of division between religions , castes to keep all bharatiyas disunited. To ensure continued hostilities between people and thereby bharath doesn't progress.
You cannot give vision to one by snatching away vision of the other , you cannot uplift one by pushing down the other.
Objective of the democracy is to treat all equally. Nobody is superior nor inferior, all are EQUALS.
More than democracy, Constitution of india HUMANITY is superior. Everyone gets human rights of equality and equal opportunity by birth. Government sponsored reservation policy is inhuman and violates human rights of poor and numerically weak people. Now in practice downtrodden identified by government are GOVERNMENT BRAHMINS and get all benefits from tax payer's money from cradle to coffin. Whereas poor among forward castes identified by government are suffering as DALITS.
Just an example a couple both of them got college seats , government jobs on reservation. Their gross monthly income is more than one lakh rupees. They get priority house, site allotment from government on caste basis. Still they apply for reservation , monetary support from government for their son's college admission. They get it.
Whereas a poor forward caste person who earns Rs.300 daily wages is unable to provide for his son's education and his son also becomes a daily wage labourer.
Is this the objective our government of india ? Government is sowing , watering the plants of division ( sowed by britishers ) in the name of reservation policy.
Nobody should be discriminated on the basis of caste or religion. It has happened in history which is INHUMAN and must be corrected. Brahmins are also one of the culprits but not the only one. There were other major culprits, castes but nobody raises voice against those numerically strong people. Just take the recent case of a village in Tamilnadu where dominant castes refused entry of dalits into temple and excreta was mixed in drinking water tank and all dalit villagers were made to drink that excreta water for weeks. Where are the voices of Mr.stalin and other brahmin haters ?
A crime cannot be corrected by another crime. Hate , Vengeance doesn't bring happiness. Equality cannot be achieved by british seeds of caste division like reservation policy. It can be achieved by change of mindset by mutual respect , love , empathy between people which brings peace , prosperity and happiness. We respect all religions and castes. There are rich as well as poor in all castes and religions. Poor in all castes and communities deserve government support but rich does not deserve it.
Your's
Nagaraja.M.R
Reservation policy cannot stay for indefinite period, says Supreme Court
Justice P.B. Pardiwala, who also formed the majority which upheld EWS quota, says real solution lies in eliminating causes that have led to the social, educational and economic backwardness of the weaker sections of the community
A bench of Supreme Court judges during a verdict on 10% quota in colleges and government jobs for the poor or EWS (Economically Weaker Sections), in New Delhi on November 7, 2022.
Three judges on the Constitution Bench, in views which formed both the majority and minority opinions, said the policy of reservation in education and employment cannot continue for an indefinite period.
Justice Bela M. Trivedi, who was part of the majority judgment, said reservation policy must have a time span. “At the end of 75 years of our Independence, we need to revisit the system of reservation in the larger interest of the society as a whole, as a step forward towards transformative constitutionalism,” Justice Trivedi said.
She pointed out that quota for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in the House of the People and in State Legislative Assemblies would cease 80 years from the commencement of the Constitution. The representation of Anglo-Indian communities in Parliament and Assemblies has already stopped by virtue of the 104th Constitutional Amendment from January 25, 2020.
“Therefore, a similar time limit, if prescribed, for the special provisions in respect of the reservations and representations provided in Article 15 and Article 16 of the Constitution, it could be a way forward leading to an egalitarian, casteless and classless society,” Justice Trivedi observed.
Though not expressly said, Justice Trivedi’s view on stopping quota under Articles 15 and 16 would also encompass EWS reservation.
Justice P.B. Pardiwala, who also formed the majority which upheld the EWS quota, said “reservation is not an end but a means — a means to secure social and economic justice. Reservation should not be allowed to become a vested interest. Real solution, however, lies in eliminating the causes that have led to the social, educational and economic backwardness of the weaker sections of the community”.
He said “longstanding development and the spread of education” had resulted in tapering the gap between the classes to a considerable extent. Large percentages of Backward Class members attain acceptable standards of education and employment. They should be removed from the Backward categories so that attention could be paid toward those genuinely in need of help.
“It is very much necessary to take into review the method of identification and the ways of determination of Backward Classes, and also, ascertain whether the criteria adopted or applied for the classification of Backward is relevant for today’s conditions,” Justice Pardiwala said.
In his minority view on the Bench, Justice S. Ravindra Bhat reminded Baba Saheb Ambedkar’s observations that reservations should be seen as temporary and exceptional “or else they would eat up the rule of equality”.
DECCAN INQUIRER
Bi-Weekly e news paper
Editor: Nagaraja.M.R.... Vol.04.....Issue.42...............27 / 05 / 2023
Caste Reservation or Discrimination Vengeance ?
- An appeal to Honourable Supreme Court of India
The “Caste based Reservation Acts “ by government of india and state governments are reverse discrimination , gross violation of human rights , acts of vengeance. The authors of Constitution of India have committed crimes , human rights violations against numerically small financially socially poor castes like brahmins , vyshyas , others. Nobody , no highest constitutional functionaries, no judges have the right to violate other human being's human rights. In this backdrop authors of Constitution of india are human rights violators , criminals.
Reservation act is passed by majority in indian parliament. In the same way during Hitler's reign Oppressive policies against jews were passed by majority in german parliament. Mere majority , mere numbers cannot make an inhuman act into humane or injustice into justice.
Our freedom fighters struggled, sacrificed to build an ideal country free from any biases. Freedom fighters belonging to all castes, religions including brahmins, dalits , muslims , others have sacrificed a lot in freedom struggle. After independence people belonging to all castes and religions are paying taxes to the government. In spite of all this numerically dominant castes are usurping public resources , opportunities by suppressing , discriminating numerically minor castes like brahmins , vyshyas. Where is equality , equal opportunity?
Every human being including brahmins have human rights of equal rights , equal opportunity and equitable justice even if Constitution cheats them of the same.
The Caste based reservation acts are passed by majority in parliament fine. In the same way inhuman acts of suppression of Jews were passed by majority in Nazi Germany parliament. Brute numerical majority doesn't make an inhuman act as human or injustice as justice.
From time immemorial numerically dominant castes were ruling village panchayaths to big kingdoms. People of dominant castes were village panchayath heads to kings, they ruled enforced discriminatory rules , untouchability in their jurisdictions.
Today's parliament and state legislature s since independence are occupied by dominant caste members. They have made brahmins as scape goats for all the ills , untouchability. Does it mean kings & village panchayath heads of yester years were foolish and acted as per brahmin's advices only ? Then why don't you credit brahmins for good things done in yester years ?
Every caste and religion including brahmins are guilty of practicing untouchability against dalits but not brahmins alone.
Only dalits need caste based affirmative actions to remove caste based social stigma.
All other castes , religions doesn't need OBC , GROUP A , GROUP B , etc tags and reservation. They must get affirmative actions based on their economic status rather than their caste. Numerically , politically dominant castes have usurped public resources by classifying their own castes as backward.
There are rich as well as poor people in all castes and religions. Poor in all castes and religions need support by government and society. But rich people in so called reserved category doesn't need government support instead it must be given to the poor among the same reserved category. Affirmative actions must be based on latest transparent people census including details of caste , religion , education , property , income , etc not on decades old census. There is a huge change from 1947 to 2023.
Children should not be punished for the crimes committed by their grand father.
Also punishing a criminal ( of minor caste) for his crimes is right but letting his accomplices, crime partners ( belonging to dominant castes ) free is not right.
Now many state governments have unscientifically declared people of dominant castes as backward castes and granted them reservation benefits even crossing 50% reservation cap by SCI. There are many families of reserved category where both parents are government employees and getting more than one lakh rupees monthly salary , still government declares them backward and their son gets fee waiver , scholarships , etc in college. Whereas a brahmin worker earning three hundred rupees in daily wages is declared as forward caste by government and his son studying in college is denied fee waiver scholarships , etc like his backward class classmate. Unable to pay fees he drops out of college.
Is this the India our freedom fighters struggled sacrificed for ?
Hereby we appeal to Honourable Supreme Court of India :
1. To order government of india and state governments to conduct time bound transparent people census.
2. To annul all discriminatory reservation acts by government.
3. To order government to base it's affirmative policies on actual conditions of people irrespective of caste or religion.
4. To limit reservation benefits only once to a family. Father gets job on reservation quota again his son should not get job on reservation instead a person of same reserved category who has not got reservation benefits earlier should get it.
5. To provide equal opportunity for every person irrespective of caste or religion in all spheres.
Your's sincerely
Nagaraja M R
Dr.B.R.Ambedkar against permanent Reservation Policy
In his minority view on the Bench, Justice S. Ravindra Bhat reminded Baba Saheb Ambedkar’s observations that reservations should be seen as temporary and exceptional “or else they would eat up the rule of equality”.
Reservation or Oppression or Vengeance ?
A GO issued by the Madras Presidency in 1921 allocated 44% of reservations to non-Brahmins, 16% to Muslims, 16% to Anglo-Indian Christians, and 8% to Scheduled Castes. 100% fully reserved. No jobs , no college seats, no government support for Brahmins. Are not brahmins citizens of india ? Are not brahmins tax payers to the government ? There are many Brahmins who struggled and sacrificed for our freedom struggle like other communities.
Britishers sowed the seeds of division between religions , castes to keep all bharatiyas disunited. To ensure continued hostilities between people and thereby bharath doesn't progress.
You cannot give vision to one by snatching away vision of the other , you cannot uplift one by pushing down the other.
Objective of the democracy is to treat all equally. Nobody is superior nor inferior, all are EQUALS.
More than democracy, Constitution of india HUMANITY is superior. Everyone gets human rights of equality and equal opportunity by birth. Government sponsored reservation policy is inhuman and violates human rights of poor and numerically weak people. Now in practice downtrodden identified by government are GOVERNMENT BRAHMINS and get all benefits from tax payer's money from cradle to coffin. Whereas poor among forward castes identified by government are suffering as DALITS.
Just an example a couple both of them got college seats , government jobs on reservation. Their gross monthly income is more than one lakh rupees. They get priority house, site allotment from government on caste basis. Still they apply for reservation , monetary support from government for their son's college admission. They get it.
Whereas a poor forward caste person who earns Rs.300 daily wages is unable to provide for his son's education and his son also becomes a daily wage labourer.
Is this the objective our government of india ? Government is sowing , watering the plants of division ( sowed by britishers ) in the name of reservation policy.
Nobody should be discriminated on the basis of caste or religion. It has happened in history which is INHUMAN and must be corrected. Brahmins are also one of the culprits but not the only one. There were other major culprits, castes but nobody raises voice against those numerically strong people. Just take the recent case of a village in Tamilnadu where dominant castes refused entry of dalits into temple and excreta was mixed in drinking water tank and all dalit villagers were made to drink that excreta water for weeks. Where are the voices of Mr.stalin and other brahmin haters ?
A crime cannot be corrected by another crime. Hate , Vengeance doesn't bring happiness. Equality cannot be achieved by british seeds of caste division like reservation policy. It can be achieved by change of mindset by mutual respect , love , empathy between people which brings peace , prosperity and happiness. We respect all religions and castes. There are rich as well as poor in all castes and religions. Poor in all castes and communities deserve government support but rich does not deserve it.
Your's
Nagaraja.M.R
Reservation policy cannot stay for indefinite period, says Supreme Court
Justice P.B. Pardiwala, who also formed the majority which upheld EWS quota, says real solution lies in eliminating causes that have led to the social, educational and economic backwardness of the weaker sections of the community
A bench of Supreme Court judges during a verdict on 10% quota in colleges and government jobs for the poor or EWS (Economically Weaker Sections), in New Delhi on November 7, 2022.
Three judges on the Constitution Bench, in views which formed both the majority and minority opinions, said the policy of reservation in education and employment cannot continue for an indefinite period.
Justice Bela M. Trivedi, who was part of the majority judgment, said reservation policy must have a time span. “At the end of 75 years of our Independence, we need to revisit the system of reservation in the larger interest of the society as a whole, as a step forward towards transformative constitutionalism,” Justice Trivedi said.
She pointed out that quota for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in the House of the People and in State Legislative Assemblies would cease 80 years from the commencement of the Constitution. The representation of Anglo-Indian communities in Parliament and Assemblies has already stopped by virtue of the 104th Constitutional Amendment from January 25, 2020.
“Therefore, a similar time limit, if prescribed, for the special provisions in respect of the reservations and representations provided in Article 15 and Article 16 of the Constitution, it could be a way forward leading to an egalitarian, casteless and classless society,” Justice Trivedi observed.
Though not expressly said, Justice Trivedi’s view on stopping quota under Articles 15 and 16 would also encompass EWS reservation.
Justice P.B. Pardiwala, who also formed the majority which upheld the EWS quota, said “reservation is not an end but a means — a means to secure social and economic justice. Reservation should not be allowed to become a vested interest. Real solution, however, lies in eliminating the causes that have led to the social, educational and economic backwardness of the weaker sections of the community”.
He said “longstanding development and the spread of education” had resulted in tapering the gap between the classes to a considerable extent. Large percentages of Backward Class members attain acceptable standards of education and employment. They should be removed from the Backward categories so that attention could be paid toward those genuinely in need of help.
“It is very much necessary to take into review the method of identification and the ways of determination of Backward Classes, and also, ascertain whether the criteria adopted or applied for the classification of Backward is relevant for today’s conditions,” Justice Pardiwala said.
In his minority view on the Bench, Justice S. Ravindra Bhat reminded Baba Saheb Ambedkar’s observations that reservations should be seen as temporary and exceptional “or else they would eat up the rule of equality”.
Edited, printed , published owned by NAGARAJA.M.R. @ # LIG-2 No 761, HUDCO FIRST STAGE , OPP WATER WORKS , LAXMIKANTANAGAR , HEBBAL ,MYSURU – 570017 KARNATAKA INDIA Cell : 91 8970318202
WhatsApp 91 8970318202
Home page :
https://e-inquirer.blogspot.com/
Contact :
naag@gmx.com
.jpeg)
Comments
Post a Comment